Yeah Elites and rares don't do extra damage anymore. They are merely a preference of look and color.
And that's enough for me.
I am pleased to announce that I tamed Humar the Pridelord last night (this morning?) at approximately 2 a.m. Central. I was up late planning a trip anyway, so I decided to log back in, quickly fly from Astraanar to Ratchet, and check Humar's spawn--and there he was!
I threw on Aspect of the Monkey, got just inside range for Tame Beast, and started the taming. I had a sliver of health left when I finished, but I survived! I think those awesome pieces of gear I picked up in Blackfathom Depths helped. I'm still somewhat surprised I survived the encounter, given that Humar is a level 23 Elite, my character is a level 24 Hunter, and I didn't have any buffs (besides Aspect of the Monkey) on.
(In hindsight, I should have set a Freezing Trap, but in the excitement of the moment, I completely forgot. I also forgot to take a screenshot of the taming process, but I feel less embarrassed about that since taking a screenshot sometimes causes a tiny bit of lag and that might have been enough to get me killed.)
In keeping with general Internet policy, here's proof I did indeed tame Humar:
I have 3 stable slots (the holding slot and 2 purchased slots), so I'd like to take the Ghost Saber in Darkshore now. Anyone have a Dwarf character above level 30 on Madoran that could help?
EDIT: Of course, the irony is that I never tamed Humar with Ulfbrikt and now I've tamed him with only 2 days left on my account. D'oh! Oh well. He'll be there if/when I come back.