Cell phone/smartphone advice

Tek7

CGA President, Tribe of Judah Founder & President
Staff member
My wife and I are seriously considering ditching AT&T in favor of Sprint. We're hoping to move from regular ol' cell phones to smartphones and the Samsung Replenish seems to be the best bang for the buck.

We don't want iPhones and we want TRUE unlimited data. Last I checked, AT&T caps data at 2GB and purposely cripples the Android OS on their phones so users' selection of Android apps they can install is limited (likely to prevent tethering).

Thoughts?
 
I love sprint's prices and they have decent phones.

Use this CFOs blog to get friends and family rate and save a BUNDLE!
Sprint employees are entitled to an unlimited number of referrals per calendar year.
http://mcguireslaw.com/ Look on the right side!
Special Sprint offer (enter Russ.S.McGuire@Sprint.com and 383)

unlimited data and unlimited mobile to ANY mobile ANY carrier is amazing!

PS they are getting the iPhone soon too.
Also you can turn your android into a mobile WiFi hotspot for free!
 
Last edited:
Also the Replenish won't have Flash Player FYI, that's kinda deal breaker for some. Personally I have not found it to be that big a deal.
 
Any smartphone would be a huge upgrade for us. We're currently using Samsung A737s. Well, my wife would be using hers still if it hadn't started acting up. :(

My wife's friend's husband works for Sprint, so we already have an employee referral code. For our purposes, though, using our AAA discount (10% off the plan plus they waive the activation fees) may server us better. We'll have to check the numbers.

No Flash in browser IS a bummer, but I don't think it's a dealbreaker. I did read the phone has ridiculously low onboard storage, but I'll have to check the specs and compare to other phones first.

The major advantage of the Replenish is that Sprint will drop the $10 smartphone penalty (that's per phone, not per plan) for the life of the phone until July 23. That's a difference of $20 a month. Plus there's a $125 refund after 61 days of service with each Replenish. When working out the numbers for the first year, the difference between a standard phone and the Replenish is insignificant, so we'd likely opt for the smartphone, even if it is on the low end.

My major concerns with the phone are:

Sturdiness. Phone insurance is $7 per phone per month, which means an extra $14 tacked on to our bill. My wife and I are typically VERY careful with our electronics, but things happen. Still, $168 a year for "what if" scenarios seems a bit steep.

Storage space. I'm the kind of guy who likes to push his hardware to the limit, so I'll likely go on a downloading spree as soon as I have the phone in hand. If I have to load apps and games from a microSD card and if loading from the microSD card takes long than loading from onboard storage (which I'm nearly certain it will), that's going to be a hassle--for me, not necessarily for my wife.

Compatibility. I know the phone won't play Angry Birds and that's not a big deal (though it would have been nice to have a portable copy of Angry Birds without buying a PSP; I have the Minis version). But the fact that Angry Birds won't play on the phone begs the question: Why not? And what else won't run on the phone? One of the main reasons we're dropping AT&T is because they take away user choices to push users toward unnecessary add-on services and products. If it's a choice between a crippled version of Android and no Android at all, I'll opt for no Android at all. It's that simple.

My one major concern with Spring is roaming.

I plan on calling the Sprint store tomorrow to ask how roaming works, if the phone has a prompt when roaming so you don't have to check the screen every time you make a call. (I plan on using a Bluetooth headset and voice commands for most calls.)

So that's the deal. I'm off to compare specs and read up on roaming now!

EDIT: One more thing: I DO want to tether with my phone if I get a smartphone.

EDIT#2: After reading reviews for about 10 minutes, I've come to the conclusion that every phone we can afford stinks on ice. :(
 
Last edited:
Can you afford the LG optimus S ? It's 2.2, plays games like a champ and is cheap. plus it's getting gingerbread (2.3/2.4) android update soon. The Optimus S is truly a fantastic cheap full featured android that is blazing fast.
 
Last edited:
There is no roaming with Sprint, it's all unlimited for mobile to any mobile and the few time you call a land line it is covered by your anywhere minutes.

Also get a 8 gig sd card and your set. I play everything from the sd card and there is no lag at all. I play all the angry birds , plants vs zombies, and much more intense games like pocket legends. (you must play mother3 fan sub on the free and legit gba emu by the way.)
 
Last edited:
Can you afford the LG optimus S ? It's 2.2, plays games like a champ and is cheap. plus it's getting gingerbread (2.3/2.4) android update soon. The Optimus S is truly a fantastic cheap full featured android that is blazing fast.
The issue with any smartphone other than the Replenish is the $10 per phone per month penalty. If it weren't for the penalty, I'd have already decided between the Evo 4G and the Epic and kicked AT&T to the curb.
 
Ahh, bite the bullet man, the Evo and Epic are slick and you need the power of the sun in the palm of your hand. Yeah its an extra 240 a year but its 240 spent on style!
 
Ahh, bite the bullet man, the Evo and Epic are slick and you need the power of the sun in the palm of your hand. Yeah its an extra 240 a year but its 240 spent on style!
And if I was employed, I would have already had an Evo. Like, when I got my first paycheck. :)

But I'm not employed, my daughter's only 4 months old, we're still paying medical bills (though for the best cause ever), and I'm still having to pay on student loan debt even though my college degree isn't worth the paper it's printed on.

(That's also why I save up my gift money and wait until games are on really great sales before buying them. Well, that, and I'm just naturally thrifty.)

</rant>

But yes, if I had the expendable income, I agree that picking up an Evo and a better service package would be an excellent way to spend it. :)

For me, there's really no point in getting a data plan unless I get at least a mid-range smartphone (and I'd strongly prefer the Evo or Epic). The Replenish is definitely a low-end smartphone and we'd have to wait 22 months to upgrade without getting hit with a penalty.

Put another way: It's the Evo or Epic or nothing (new). The only reason we were looking at smartphones in the first place was because my wife's phone started acting up and Sprint is waiving the $10 per phone per month penalty on the Replenish AND the difference in cost between a standard plan and a better plan with unlimited data was roughly $10-15 a month.

But that's all moot now because I fixed my wife's Samsung A737...by plugging it into my computer using a USB cable.

/blink

I still can't quite believe it was that simple. But it was. I had plugged in the phone to dump files and research if it was possible to upgrade the firmware via USB and the phone just started working properly again.

So for the time being, we're going to stick with our cheesy standard phones and AT&T. But the day I get my first paycheck on a new job...
 
May I ask one question in reference to cell phones? I live in a place which due to geography, not distance, reception on AT&T is iffy a best. Can someone recommend a phone/carrier combo that excels in bad reception areas? Basic no frills phone, monthly cost 63.00 or less. Texting not desired.
 
Verizon - for the reception issue. I'm not sure about the no frills part. We had the same problem at our house. With the first cell phone we had, 12 years ago, we had to go to the end of the block to get reception. I had friends over with all their cell phone companies. Verizon won the bar battle and we have been with them ever since.

I love the way I can add and delete contract options as I need them. Go global when I went to the Middle East or Mexico and drop it as soon as I return. Same for having navigation options or backup plans or any other extra I might want to add for a month or so.

I've had regular phones - a Blackberry - and now an Android. I'm sold on the Htc Android phones. I've been using the Incredible for a while now.

I'm one of those who never got the insurance. When I went to a smart phone I started getting the insurance.
 
My wife and I have the Motorola Droid X for verizon, and we have been with verizon for 11 years and love them. We have had no problems with fixing the contracts the way we need them.
 
We switched from Cingular (now AT&T) to Verizon a long time ago and never looked back.

One thing to consider is what carrier(s) your friends and family use, as Verizon offers free minutes to anyone else that also has Verizon. Anyone we would ever call with the exception of one or two people (and the Chinese Take-out place), all have Verizon, so my wife and I are able to get the plan with the lowest minutes and it's not a problem.

We recently both just got iPhone 4s, which were $100 each after upgrade discount, 2-year contract discount, and employer discount (if applicable, check into that also - I had to ask my employer, as they didn't announce it). I'd had my old phone for over four years prior to this, so we felt it was time to get something really nice. We got a family plan for two of us with: minimum phone minutes, unlimited texting, and unlimited data. I think it totals ~$150 a month for our plan.

I know you're not wanting an iPhone, but Verizon had several smartphones available, and the employees were super helpful and did everything they could to get us what we wanted at an affordable price.
 
...and the employees were super helpful and did everything they could to get us what we wanted at an affordable price.
That's a good point I forgot to mention, Flamethrower. Support is GREAT.
 
Verizon is great. I'm waiting for the Samsung Galaxy S II to come to the states before swapping phones out again. It's outselling the iPhone in the UK right now. Sweet little piece of tech.
 
I have T-Mobile as my carrier, although with no smart phone.

Avoid them like the plague. Their reception stinks - I almost always have to go outside for a signal where ever I am.

I believe Sprint uses Verizon's network, so the coverage should be great. I'm going to look at them as soon as I get off my mom's contract.
 
May I ask one question in reference to cell phones? I live in a place which due to geography, not distance, reception on AT&T is iffy a best. Can someone recommend a phone/carrier combo that excels in bad reception areas? Basic no frills phone, monthly cost 63.00 or less. Texting not desired.

I would venture to say that if geography is the problem, you wil want to see if there is a cell phone tower that is in a better location than what AT&T is broadcasting from. If so, go with whoever is broadcasting from the better tower. If not, you might look into getting a Wilson Amplifier. They are some of our best sellers where I work -kinda spendy, but worth it if you plan on living at that location for a while.
 
The place is paid for so I will be living here until I get promoted to Glory. The problem isn't necessarily distance, but I live deep in a hollow, part way up a hill side. They have to pump sunshine in to my place. Sometimes I get a partial signal, sometimes I have to walk half way down the hill, sometimes all the way down the hill(despite Drs. restrictions). And then there are days I have to drive a mile 1/2 to get to the main highway for a signal. Thanks for all the tips tho, much to think on. I am looking for a basic phone that takes a mini SD card.
 
You might also want to look into getting a phone with Wifi calling support. My wife and I just made the jump to smartphones and T-Mobil seemed to have the best pricing plans for our needs. We'd heard mixed reviews on their network, but both our phones support Wifi calling, so with the fact that home and work locations all have wireless access, we made the jump. Haven't had any problems so far, and we've had the phones for about a month. We were even getting signal in the middle of the desert in Arizona last week - I was really surprised at that.

Plus, the HTC Sensation is sweeeet. =)
 
Back
Top