well, I didn't think to check on this thread before I got it, but I picked up the wii version, and I have to say it's pretty cool, even if it is just a near direct port... You can resize each of the screens depending on what you need to see, which is handy, and the nunchuck controls, like tek mentioned, are better than the ds pad. Also, I've learned not to trust critics of videogames who are paid to play them. often times they are rushed when they review them, due to deadlines and having to review so many, which in turn makes their experience less fun, considering they must rush through asap and they get less chance to actually just sit back relax and enjoy the game. But that's just me. If I see a game I'm interested in, I'll ask my friends who have played it for their opinion and go by that.