If you can deal with a bit of a change in style, I can provide that....
Ok, I'm a Noob to Redeemed (my main on Stonemaul is actually Meltaway), but I would strongly suggest an updating of the front page at this point. I've had my eye on Redeemed for quite a while before joining, but one thing that made me pause back in the Fall was thinking that you guys couldn't get past Vael in BWL, as implied by your page at
http://www.toj.cc/wow/ . You guys seemed like an end-game group that was stuck (I saw one decent end game guild that could never get past Razorgore sadly). Now I don't want to make 'end game' more than it is, but a lot of guys are keen on beating end game, and can't get as excited about a guild that's stuck permanently at a boss.
A month ago I looked further into the forums and realized you were beating Karazhan, quite an accomplishment that says something different.
So my point is, good Christian players whom you might really like to have, may well be passing you by, even if regretting doing so, because choosing a Christ-centered guild over a guild capable of doing end-game content is a tough one for them to make. So....your front page showing MC/BWL/Ony is hurting you; really needs an update, if NattyG is offering....