Gerbil's Old Movie Recommendations

The Mighty Gerbil

Tribe of Judah TF 2 Chapter Leader & CGA Admin
Staff member
Gerbil's Old Movie/Show Recommendations

In my efforts to make the world a better place I say to you all watch something old! 9 times out of 10 older films are written better, acted better and have higher standards of morality (even when some of the people in them don't). Many old films never get watched as only the most known old films get aired enough for people to know them. For example "It's a Wonderful Life" with Frank Capra and Jimmy Stewart who did many other movies just as good as it if not better! To which end I have started this thread to support older movies and ween people a little off of the junk made nowadays which is usually at best mindless fluff. No movie/show is perfect and neither are these but they are, by and large, so much better than today's stuff and do not deserve to be forgotten. Do try to be fair to these films. They don't have the latest CGI but I will consider you shallow if you cannot watch a film simply because it's in black and white >.< (though not every film/show I recommend will be).

I'll try to post links to Hulu and Netflix. I also tried to select movies you can watch instantly and will note if otherwise. My movie sections will be divided by red titles look for them for easy finding. Please use another color on yours so people can find mine easy TY.

First (and with Tek in Mind)...

Akira Kurosawa Films
These films both feel old and new at the same time with the distinctly Japanese overacting flavor (like Anime has). These movies probably have the most objectionable content I will ever post in this thread and it's not much at all. A couple words in the subtitles and a spartan couple gore moments with 1950's grade effects (there is no nudity in the ones I've watched). These movies are very good inspiring other great works and being inspired by other great works. I can see why Kurosawa is considered one of the best Directors ever.

The Seven Samurai
I'd start with The Seven Samurai the film which inspired the American western remake The Magnificent Seven. Quite frankly The Seven Samurai is better.

Note: There is even an Anime Samurai 7 loosely based on The Seven Samurai but trust me when I say all the best parts are taken directly from the original movie. It's not an objectionable Anime but it's not really good either. I'd skip it and watch more of the old stuff. I actually watched it on Hulu not Netflix though there are only four episodes available there now.

Yojimbo
Sanjuro
After The Seven Samurai try these two movies which inspired the classic western drifter Clint Eastwood played in the awesome Sergio Leone spaghetti westerns. In fact A Fistful of Dollars is a remake of Yojimbo although the films differ enough to make each enjoyable in it's own right.

Hidden Fortress
This one was an inspiration to George Lucas narrating the Star Wars trilogy through the eyes of the bit players C3PO and R2D2. If I recall this is the one that had a little language in the subtitles but nothing else.

I've also watched Ran and Throne of Blood which are Japanese interpretations of Shakespeare's plays. Neither is an instant play on Netflix unfortunately. While Ran is good I felt the acting was overtly emotional and drug out at points compared to other Kurosawa films.

Tek mentioned watching Kurosawa's Dreams but I expect it's much tripper than other Kurosawa films. Kurosawa said in an interview something to the effect of "when you're old you don't care what people think anymore so you just do what you want" and so he made Dreams :p . IDK if it's bad or good having not seen it but it's bound to be a completely different animal than his earlier films. I would not gauge them by each other.

Here Comes the Groom


Here Comes the Groom
Next up a Bing Crosby movie! It does not have Bing Crosby's very best songs but the man could make a laundry list sound good and still does so here. I mean the film was only nominated for a best writing Oscar and won for best song :) (this is back when the Oscars were not a sham). Directed by Frank Capra, costumes by Edith Head, famous cameos, witty dialogue this is one of the many, many wonderful movies of that age...

That's all for the moment there are still droves upon droves of wonderful old movies most people never see but I am going to take my time recommending ones and avoid the few flops there are (mostly later stuff). Humprey Bogart, Edward G Robertson, Cary Grant, Alfred Hitchcock, Danny K, Bob Hope, Gene Kelly, Jimmy Stewart, Dorothy Lamour, Jimmy Cagney, etc. the list of great actors and movies stretches a mile.
 
Last edited:
Actually I have watched many of the old movies of the past. But with many Netflix titles out, I tend to not rewatch movies I've already seen. The Treasure of the Sierra Madre is a top 10 favorite ;)
 
Actually I have watched many of the old movies of the past. But with many Netflix titles out, I tend to not rewatch movies I've already seen. The Treasure of the Sierra Madre is a top 10 favorite ;)

The Treasure of the Sierra Madre is an excellent film (ever wonder where the Engineer's dance in TF2 came from people?).

Believe me when I say though even if you've watched many old movies there are more out there just waiting to be found. We are talking about lifetimes of people's work. 90% of our instant queue is old movies but I only want to post really good ones people haven't seen (avoiding obvious ones like Wizard of Oz etc.) lest I scare the old-phobic off.

It took me several hours to make up the first post so updates won't be frequent but I should have some occasionally. That's one reason why I didn't make more recommendations yet. Also Netflix has selective ones for instant watching that limits me too. I am going to have to post some normal rents eventually.
 
Last edited:
- Big Trouble in Little China
- Bird Cage
- Bloodsport
- Dick Tracy
- F/X 2
- Heat
- Hudson Hawk
- JCVD
- Lawrence of Arabia
- Patlabor
- Patlabor 2
- Red heat
- Rocketeer
- Spy game
- The Last Starfighter
- The Thing
- United 93
- Virtuosity
- Virus
- Village of the damned

Few movies are newer but I talked to most Americans and they haven't seen, United 93. Weird. :confused:
 
Last edited:
Do silents make the grade or not? There are several good ones out there. Three war movies I would put on the list that show a movie can be good with out buckets of fake blood and guts:
Stalag 17
Bridge over The River Kwai
The Colditz Story (the original 50's movie)
 
Last edited:
Do silents make the grade or not?

Indeed they do in fact...

Buster Keaton films
(can you take the silent treatment?)

Overshadowed by Chaplin (whom I do not like) Keaton's comedy is timeless and some of his stunts are just as dangerous as modern ones. Quite frankly they are even more dangerous than modern ones as this is a time without modern safety gear. Keaton even broke his neck once and didn't know it until years later. Keaton is in fact one of the inspirations for Jackie Chan who recreated some of his stunts in homage. Recreating one stunt in particular Jackie was so scared he had to just hang there until his arms gave out and he dropped, Keaton did it first. Keaton's humor itself is miles beyond simple slapstick and feels so modern. You'll need to pay attention to his reactions or you'll miss half the endearment though. The interplay between his girl and him in The General is something that never gets old.

The General (yes he is fighting on the Confederate side got a problem with it Yankee? I'm kidding :p )
College
Steamboat Bill Jr. Actually going to re-watch this one it's been so long since I've seen it. The famous house falling on Keaton scene is in it if I remember correctly.
 
Last edited:
The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly? Does that qualify even with the cussing?

:D

It's ok :) . It's just a bit obvious for a selection so I would not have used it. It didn't really have that much cussing except from Tuco and even that was only a couple moments. Also the cussing actually had a point in that film showing the type of person Tuco was. It was largely not just for the sake of throwing in cussing like most other films.

I'm not going to grade other people's ideas. I think people have different ideas about the term "old movie" depending how old they are XD. Just don't use my text color so people can find my movies easily :) .

Stormy Weather

Stormy Weather
I watched this movie a while back and it was mentioned in another thread, I checked and it is still a watch it now on Netflix. I do not like modern African American comedies as many are to busy telling the world they are black to make anything decent. However this one is one of the few old ones and quite good. Basically a showcase of talent with a loose plot hanging it together.
 
Last edited:
Metropolis (The black and white 1927 version)
Lifeboat (unfortunately dvd only on Netflix)
 
Last edited:
Lifeboat (unfortunately dvd only on Netflix)

You thought of it too! :)

Lifeboat

Lifeboat
Other Hitchcock films get the press so this one gets overlooked in my opinion so it's perfect for this thread. I, like Ursen, was only stopped from posting about it due to the lack of instant watching. It's got good acting, Hitchcock's directing and it's interesting being filmed entirely on one boat. William Bendix is also one of the many bit character actors from the time that are like watching old friends after a while (hey look it's that guy from etc.). I like how Hitchcock squeezed in his cameo on a boat in the middle of nowhere too :) .

Though I really can't say why I like the film so much without ruining it. So I will say it in a spoiler as this is a deep topic and bears expounding upon. The film is one of the extreme few that actual avoids a deep complaint I have about the typical media.
A lot of films have the "mastermind" type bad guy. Typically he manipulates and sends henchmen never doing his own work yet the hero will never kill him until the end. Even then the mastermind will typically pick up a weapon, accidentally fall to his death or do something that removes the burden of acting outside the law or making a judgment call from the hero. In this film they just kill him period. It's like the moronic reasons Batman can't kill the Joker. Do you care about people or not Batman because you ought to be pretty sure by now he is going to kill more people and the law can't hold him. Why can't he kill him? Because he would have to act outside the bounds of the approval of people (that and you couldn't have the Joker in another comic if he were dead :p ). See in life some people murder with their words like those who indoctrinate children into being terrorist bombers. You can argue with these people forever but at some point you will miss talking to one of their protegees and then boom. Such a choice to kill should never be made lightly but passing it to others all the time shouldn't be an option to a true hero. A hero does the hard things that is what makes him a hero. It's not a question of vengeance or hate it's a question of doing what is right by God without the approval of others. In this film it's clear the bad guy will just keep leading people to their doom by his words. The only other media I can remember this being addressed in is C.S. Lewis's Perelandra but then that guy was possessed by the devil. Once it dawns on him the argument will be endless and he will just keep coming back he just kills the bad guy. Killing a person outright is the final option. It should never be done without thought, prayer or exhausting all other options but it has to be done sometimes.
 
Last edited:
Harvey - Proves that good comedy does not have to contain profanity.
12 Angry Men - Another excellent film down all in a small space.
Anatomy of a Murder
 
Harvey - Proves that good comedy does not have to contain profanity.
12 Angry Men - Another excellent film down all in a small space.
Anatomy of a Murder

I will second Harvey and 12 Angry Men (and add another of my own at the bottom). I actually have not seen Anatomy of a Murder so I cannot recommend it but it was already in our queue.

Harvey Netflix instant
Harvey
It's instant, Jimmy Stewart and good.

12 Angry Men Not an instant watch
12 Angry Men
When a movie takes place entirely in one room the actors skill will either make the film or break it. 12 Angry Men pulls it off big time becoming a film I'll always remember. I don't think the big name actors we have today could pull this off :( . My father actually had a real life experience on Jury Duty once not totally unlike this.

No Time For Sergeants Not an instant watch
No Time For Sergeants
Before Forest Gump, before Gomer Pyle or the Andy Griffith show Andy Griffith actually played a part similar to Gomer's. Actually before this movie No Time For Sergeants was a Broadway play and novel. In fact Don Knotts first met Andy Griffith when he auditioned for that play. Anywho enjoy the silly fun!
 
Last edited:
To Kill a Mockingbird - if you haven't watched it yet, then you're not American :D

A favorite Hitchcock film: Rear Window

Admittedly, I do enjoy watching Natalie Wood films. She died too young :(
 
Funny, I've seen most of the movies that Gerbil has posted.

Humphrey Bogart (quite possibly my favorite actor)
Key Largo
The Maltese Falcon
Casablanca (already mentioned earlier in this thread)
Dark Passage
The African Queen

Danny Kaye
The Court Jester
The Secret Life of Walter Mitty (a very, very loose adaptation of the short story)

John Wayne
The Quiet Man
The Man who Shot Liberty Valence
The Searchers
Sons of Katie Elder

Gregory Peck
The Big Country (my favorite western)
The Gunfighter
The Guns of Navarone
 
Last edited:
Mr Smith Goes to Washington - Unfortunately this fine film is only available on DVD with Netflix.
It's A Wonderful Life - Again DVD only on Netflix.
Winchester 73 - for those who love Jimmy Stewart Westerns.
Night of the Hunter - Why does Netflix only make some of the best available on DVD? For those of you familiar with the silent films, there is a great performance by Lillian Gish. And Robert Mitchum uses his fine voice to sing a song with a tremendous, thrilling, spooky feel.
 
Last edited:
I forgot to add the classic Disney movies:

Swiss Family Robinson
Third Man on the Mountain
Darby O'Gill and the Little People
20,000 Leagues Under the Sea
The Absent-Minded Professor
 
I haven't got back to writing up movies at length but I noticed netflix had the below movie on instant and as such am recommending it.

The Women in the Window Netflix instant
The Woman in the Window
With Edward G. Robinson this movie is example of how old movies handed mature concepts without being explicit and is an excellent movie too. I don't care what some reviewers think about the ending I really liked it. It was funny, relate-able, morally instructional and well I don't want to spoil it for you (though it has been much copied) :) . They also have Scarlet Street which is "meh". Although Scarlet Street features different characters it feels like a sequel cash in and Robinson's character has none of the endearment of The Woman in the Window .
 
Last edited:
Ace in the Hole Netflix instant but only until 6/30/12!!!!!!

Link

Follow a reporter's struggle between personal success (a.k.a sin, lust and greed), conscience and the consequences there of. It shows the dark insanity media can bring people to. You might think it's over the top but remember people actually do things like sell t-shirts and write songs about things like this. The carnival appears to be a direct metaphor for the real media's circus. Made in 1951 media exploitation is still the standard today, there is truly nothing new under the sun. It's a well acted movie where one can see the thoughts of a people without them blatantly stating them. Watch it now before they take it off Netflix, it's worth it! Tell the truth.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top